Nonprofit Insurance Checkup: Starting the Year the Right Way

January always feels like a reset.

Budgets are fresh. Calendars are empty again. Boards are re-energized. And somewhere in the middle of all that optimism is a folder called “insurance” that most nonprofits would rather not open.

But this is actually the best time to do it.

An insurance checkup at the beginning of the year is not about nitpicking policies or planning for worst case scenarios. It is about making sure your coverage still lines up with the organization you are running today, not the one you were running three years ago.

Why a yearly checkup is worth the time

Most nonprofits do not stay still. Programs grow. Staff roles change. Volunteers rotate. New technology sneaks in quietly and becomes essential overnight.

Insurance, on the other hand, has a habit of staying exactly the same unless someone asks the right questions.

That disconnect is where problems usually start.

A quick annual review helps catch issues early, before they turn into stressful conversations or uncovered claims.

Start with how your work has changed

Instead of starting with policy language, start with your operations.

Did you add a new program last year?

Are you hosting more events or working offsite more often?

Did virtual services become a permanent part of how you operate?

Even small changes can affect liability exposure. Coverage that fit perfectly a few years ago may no longer tell the full story of what your organization does today.

Board changes matter more than people realize

January is also a common time for board transitions. New members bring new energy, but they also bring new risk exposure.

Directors and Officers insurance is meant to protect board members when they make decisions in good faith. It only works well if the policy is active, current, and properly structured.

This is also a good moment to make sure board members understand what is covered and what is not. That clarity goes a long way toward confident leadership.

Employment risk is not just a big organization problem

Even small nonprofits deal with hiring, performance issues, and tough conversations. Employment related claims do not only happen at large organizations with HR departments.

If your staff has grown, your policies have changed, or expectations around workplace behavior have shifted, it is worth reviewing how your coverage lines up with reality.

Insurance works best when it supports good policies and clear communication, not when it is treated as a backup plan.

Cyber risk is now part of daily operations

If your nonprofit takes online donations, stores donor information, or uses cloud based tools, cyber risk is already part of your world.

Many organizations are surprised to learn what their cyber coverage does and does not include. Older policies may not reflect how data is actually used today.

An annual checkup is a chance to understand what happens if something goes wrong, before you are forced to find out the hard way.

Property values change even if buildings do not

Construction costs rise. Equipment ages. Improvements add value.

Property coverage that has not been reviewed in years often falls short when a loss happens. Updating values now can prevent painful gaps later.

This is one of the most common issues nonprofits discover during a review.

Make it a simple habit, not a stressful event

An insurance checkup does not have to be complicated. It can be a conversation. A checklist. A short meeting once a year.

What matters is making it intentional.

When insurance is reviewed early in the year, there is time to make thoughtful changes instead of rushed decisions during renewal season.

Starting the year with fewer unknowns

Nonprofits do important work. Insurance should support that work quietly in the background, not create anxiety or confusion.

Taking a little time at the start of the year to check in on your coverage helps leadership focus on mission instead of risk.

It is not about buying more insurance.

It is about knowing you are covered in the ways that actually matter.

‍